Principles

Remediation

Disorganized Developments v SA [2023] HCA 22

Hells Angels is a criminal organisation.  Two members were directors of Disorganized, which owned land at Cowirra.  It is an offence for members of a criminal organisation to enter property declared a ‘prescribed place’11.  Regulations sought to (but did not on their face) declare the land a ‘prescribed place’.  After conviction, …

Singular meaning

MK v R [2023] NSWCCA 180

MK was convicted of maintaining an ‘unlawful sexual relationship’ with a child13.  That term is defined as ‘a relationship in which an adult engages in 2 or more unlawful sexual acts towards a child over any period’. Two earlier cases held that a sexual relationship over and above commission of the offences …

Adding words

CEO v Waroona Resources [2023] WASCA 73

Regulations exempted ‘asbestos containing material’6  – defined as ‘manufactured material … that, as part of its design, contains asbestos’ – from levy calculation.  Waroona said this should be read as including a mix of asbestos and soil where separation was impracticable.

Waroona argued that the levy’s purpose of encouraging recycling did not …

Extrinsic materials

Doman v Leadenhall Australia [2023] SASC 97

This case is about the effect of bankruptcy on judgment debt interest.  It is important for two reasons.  First is the principle that statutes – in this case, the Bankruptcy Act 1966 – override the common law to the extent of any inconsistency.  Second is the discussion by McDonald J (at [50-57]) about …

Statutory definitions

Azimitabar v Commonwealth [2023] FCA 760

Statutory definitions, as mere aids to construction, are usually unable to confer powers10.  In this case, the definition of ‘immigration detention’ seemed to allow the minister to approve ‘another place’ as an immigration detention centre.  A delegate purported to use the power to approve the Mantra Hotel as such a centre.  This …

Words with a legal meaning

Host-Plus v Maritime Super [2023] NSWSC 725

Did an asset transfer from one superfund to another involve an ‘appointment’ for the purpose of unlawful inducement provisions13?  The word ‘appointment’ has a well-understood legal meaning in trust situations14.  Words with a legal meaning when used in a statute take that meaning ‘unless a contrary meaning clearly appears …

Frequent amendment

DMQ20 v Minister [2023] FCAFC 84

Generally, the same expression in a statute takes the same meaning, while different expressions indicate different meanings.  This is not to be pressed too far, and ‘is of very slight force’ if the words are clear7.

The presumption is also muted where differences in wording can be attributed to the scope or …

Constructional choice

DN v Secretary [2023] NSWSC 595

The issue was whether the Children’s Court had jurisdiction to vary a care order made after children were placed with UK carers10.  The mother (DN) argued that there was no power to vary the order. 

Kunc J rejected this.  The jurisdiction of courts is to be construed broadly11, and more …

Singular and plural

Tickle v Giggle for Girls Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 553

Tickle alleged discrimination on the basis of gender identity12.  This complaint was later withdrawn and a new one lodged out of time.  Despite the ordinary position that the singular includes the plural in statutes13, Giggle argued that, for policy and finality reasons, the statute envisaged only …

Specific powers

Whitebull HTL Pty Ltd v ILGA [2023] NSWSC 588

Specific powers in a statute exclude access to more general ones15.  ILGA purported to exercise general powers under one statute to limit gaming machine numbers.  Whitebull challenged this, arguing that a second statute set out exclusively, and more precisely, how numbers were to be regulated.

McNaughton J surveyed the …