Episodes

Episode 136

Leeming JA states in a recent case1 – ‘The task is to construe the difficult language enacted, rather than better language that was not enacted’.  This arose in the context of the meaning of ‘custody’ under high risk offenders legislation, where relevance of the presumption against surplusage became an issue.  Leeming JA emphasised that the presumption is just that …

Episode 135

In a ceremonial sitting of the High Court for Sir Anthony Mason, Gageler CJ called out the late chief justice’s ‘assimilation of taxation legislation into the mainstream of statutory interpretation together with Wilson J in Cooper Brookes …’1  It was said in that case that the fact ‘that an Act is a taxing statute does not make it immune …

Episode 134

Countless are the cases where a court or tribunal sets out the basics of our ‘modern approach’ to statutory interpretation by reference to High Court authority.  One recent case is novel in this regard1.  For guidance on interpretation, Lindsay J quotes French CJ from his foreword to the 2014 edition of Pearce & Geddes2.  The main …

Episode 133

In Hopper v Victoria, the High Court held legislated caps on political donations in Victoria to be invalid1.  One issue was the effect of a severance clause in the State interpretation statute2 aimed at saving a challenged provision ‘to the extent to which it is not in excess of … power’3.  The plurality noted …

Episode 132

The High Court has clarified the meaning of ‘honest’ within the expression ‘honest concurrent use’ as a defence to trade mark infringement1.  After Firstmac registered the mark ZIP for financial products, Zip used substantially the same mark for its loan products.  It was held that Zip had failed to prove ‘honest concurrent use’.  The court noted (at [57]) …

Episode 131

The High Court refused an application by US singer Katy Perry to cancel the clothing trade mark Katie Perry held by an Australian fashion designer1.  It was argued that its use by the designer ‘would be likely to deceive or cause confusion’2.  This was due to the reputation the singer’s later trade mark Katy Perry had …

Episode 130

What is the difference between ‘ordinary meaning’ and ‘plain meaning’?  A recent American article spends 70 pages explaining the position1.  Often the two terms are used without discrimination.  In our system, ordinary meaning involves the natural way in which people use a word.  Plain meaning refers to the evident or clear meaning of a word in the sense …

Episode 129

Can statutes die of old age?  The answer seems to be ‘not in law but sometimes in practice’1.  Repeal by parliament is needed to kill them off in a legal sense.  A statute may fall into desuetude for practical purposes, however, where the ‘tooth of time’ deprives it of all factual application2.  The law is also …

Episode 128

When a public authority undertook construction of a light rail project, affected businesses sued in private nuisance for substantial interference with their use and enjoyment of their premises1.  They succeeded and were awarded damages.  The case illustrates the complexities arising at the intersection of public works and private occupation.  In the context of project legislation, the common law …

Episode 127

In Badari, access to extrinsic materials in the interpretation of court orders is considered by the High Court1.  Importantly, the court said that ‘as is generally the case with the interpretation of written instruments, there is no threshold requirement before extrinsic context can be considered’.  This appears to clear up any residual uncertainty as to whether ambiguity …