Principles

Two paths, one destination

Edelman J explains that s 15AB was enacted before the ‘modern approach’ had solidified9.  Section 15AB regulates how extrinsic materials may be used by providing gateways, conditions and processes.  But the differences between statutory and common law paths ‘should not be overstated’.  There ‘will very rarely be a difference in practice’ between them10.

Each path …

iNOW! observations

This case confirms the potential of extrinsic materials under the ‘modern approach’ to influence meaning12. 

What Edelman J said in Harvey is important for many reasons.  (1) Access to extrinsic materials is driven by the contextual focus of our system. (2) The statutory and common law paths into those materials exist side-by-side13. (3) It will be …

Appellate deference

Pritchard v M 6:8 Legal [2024] WASCA 4

The appeal court in this case makes an important point about the manner in which views of the court below on interpretation are to be approached.  It was said (at [35]) – ‘This court applies the correctness standard in reaching its own view as to the proper construction of the provisions, without …

High Court mantra

Munkara v Santos NA Barossa (No 3) [2024] FCA 9

This gas pipeline case was fought over the meaning of ‘significant new environmental impact’ in federal regulations.  Charlesworth J (at [135]) said the regulation was to be read in accordance with the Acts Interpretation Act 1901 and ‘well established principles’, quoting SZTAL [2017] HCA 34 (at [14]) –

Extrinsic materials

Harvey v Minister [2024] HCA 1

As the first case decided by the High Court this year, Harvey v Minister for Primary Industry & Resources makes important points about extrinsic materials and our ‘modern approach’ more generally.

The issue was whether a mineral lease involved a right to mine for the sole purpose of constructing an ‘infrastructure facility … associated …

Professor Pearce

Statutory Interpretation in Australia

Dennis Pearce has published the 10th edition of his classic text, a monumental achievement15.  For half a century, this book has guided courts, academics and practitioners with authority, style and perspective.  As LexisNexis says, it is the ‘most cited text on Australian law’.  The slim volume which appeared in 1974 has grown in line …

Meaning of ‘suicide’

Carr v Attorney-General [2023] FCA 1500

Federal law makes it an offence to use a carriage service to assist someone to commit ‘suicide’5.  Victoria allows doctors to prescribe a ‘voluntary assisted dying substance’ to certain persons6.  It was argued that a doctor using a carriage service in this context commits no offence, as ‘suicide’ does not …

Meaning of ‘remains’

Armitage v Parole Board Qld [2023] QCA 239

In Queensland, a ‘no body – no parole’ rule applies where ‘part of the body or remains of the victim has not been located’8.  Armitage was convicted of manslaughter, but 15% of the body was unaccounted for (hands and feet).  Did the rule apply in this case?

Flanagan JA (at …

Frustration of purpose

Mangoola v Muswellbrook SC [2023] NSWCA 275

Mangoola sought to recover $3m in overpaid council rates.  The Act said action for amounts ‘recoverable on restitutionary grounds’ had to be commenced within 12 months11 – not met.  Mangoola argued that this deadline did not apply to statutory claims.

Leeming JA said context and purpose made it clear the Act was …

Extraterritoriality

Karpik v Carnival plc [2023] HCA 39

Passengers who caught COVID on a cruise sued the vessel owner under unfair contract provisions in the Australian Consumer Law13.  One issue was whether the consumer provisions applied to contracts made offshore and to things done outside Australia.

Where the presumption of extraterritoriality arises, the ‘starting point is always the interpretation …