Principles

Commanding the impossible

SCC Plenty v Construction [2015] VSC 631

This case on adjudication mechanisms in building industry laws makes the point (at [98]) that ‘laws must not command the impossible’.  Unless flexibility was applied, said the judge, the legislation ‘could not be made to work’. 

The notion of impossibility driving interpretation is another aspect of taking practical implications into account12.  …

Meaning of ‘person’

Plaintiff M68 v Minister [2016] HCA 1

In the offshore detention case, the High Court held the Republic of Nauru to be a ‘person or body’ under regional processing amendments4.  Section 2C(1) of the Acts Interpretation Act 1901 presumes that expressions used to denote persons generally ‘include a body politic or corporate as well as an individual’.  Provisions …

Meaning of ‘Australia’

ACCC v P T Garuda Indonesia [2016] FCAFC 42

Geography is often important in the application of legislation, especially where ‘Australia’ is used.  This case was about whether an air cargo market existed ‘in Australia’.  There is a general definition of ‘Australia’ in s 2B of the Acts Interpretation Act 1901, but many federal statutes have their own definitions…

‘as amended from time to time’

Endeavour v Precision [2015] NSWCA 169

What happens when a statutory provision cross-refers to a provision in another Act and the latter is amended?  In this case, the second provision was amended after an accident to increase the liability cap.  The court held (at [76]) that the first provision picked up the second as amended from time to time.  Crucially, …

‘means X and includes Y’

Roden v Bandora Holdings [2015] NSWLEC 191

Pearce & Geddes (at [6.64]) say that using ‘means and includes’ in definitions ‘ought to be eschewed by drafters’.  This case shows why.  The issue was whether wedding venues were ‘tourist facilities’, in turn defined in the ‘means X and includes Y’ form with no reference to weddings whatsoever.

Two general problems may …

Legislative scheme

R v Host [2015] WASCA 23

When different statutes of the same legislature form a ‘legislative scheme’, courts will try to construe them ‘to produce a sensible, efficient and just operation’6.  Driven by the need for a ‘rational integration of the legislation’, this is exactly what the court did in this sentencing case (at [111]). 

As Pearce & …

Judgment words

Australian Building Systems [2015] HCA 48

When interpreting statutes, we are to start and finish with the statutory words8, not to substitute what a minister may say for those words9.  In the ABS case (at [227]), Gordon J observed that judicial decisions ‘are not substitutes for the text of legislation’ either, something that follows from the …

Delegated legislation

QBE Insurance v Mordue [2015] NSWCA 380

This case (at [92]) makes the point that delegated legislation gives way to the statute under which it is made where the two are ‘irreconcilably incompatible or inconsistent’12.  Delegated legislation includes regulations, rules, by-laws, determinations and instruments made under an Act. 

Regulations cannot control what an Act means, but they may …

Incurable defects

DPP v Walters [2015] VSCA 303

Legislation in Victoria had introduced ‘baseline sentencing’ but was ‘wholly silent’ on the means by which it was to be implemented.  The majority said (at [57]) that extrinsic materials could not be used to fill the gap15, and that any judicial action in this regard ‘would be to legislate, not interpret’. 

The …

Re-enactment

Fortress Credit v Fletcher [2015] HCA 10

What happens when parliament re-enacts words already judicially construed?  As this case explains (at [15]), parliament ‘is taken to have intended the words to bear the meaning … judicially attributed to [them]’2.  This presumption does not bite in all situations3, but it was applied in this case to provisions …