Principles

Always speaking

Petersen v Argentine Republic [2025] NSWSC 1071

After Argentina’s nationalisation of energy assets in 2012, a New York judge awarded US$16b in damages to P as a dispossessed party.  When P sought to enforce judgment, Argentina said relevant process had not been validly served on it, something it said could only happen under convention procedures5. 

Argentina argued that, …

Re-enactment presumption

RPPL [2025] FCA 1126; Stretton [2025] VSC 589

Two cases show how the re-enactment presumption works in practice.  In RPPL, the issue was whether jurisdiction provisions in new ART legislation are to be read the same way as in the old AAT legislation8.  Given the new provisions took into account the ‘existing well-settled position’, Cheeseman J (at …

Co-interpretation

Crossley v English [2025] WASCA 141

This water access case (at [101-106]) considers the ‘principle of co-interpretation’ – that being, when one Act amends another, the two are read together ‘as one connected and combined statement of the will of parliament’10.  The principle applies at both common law and under statute11, though the latter ‘has added …

Personal liberty

Meredith v NSW (No 5) [2025] NSWSC 1133

M headed a class action for assault [etc] after she was strip searched by police for drugs at a music festival.  Were the searches ‘necessary’ in terms of the ‘seriousness and urgency of the circumstances’14?

Necessary means ‘absolutely necessary’, and urgency indicates a situation ‘requiring immediate action or attention’.  The …

In pari materia

Grapple Pay v Conroy [2025] NSWCA 171

The Latin term in pari materia means ‘analogous’.  Parliament is presumed to intend the same words used in a later statute ‘in a similar connection’ take the same meaning7.  The practical application of this depends on the strength of the analogy in question.

In the present case, a suggested analogy between …

Enterprise agreements

Police Federation v CCP (Victoria) [2025] FCA 865

This case repeats principles applying to enterprise agreements10 but makes extra points.  One, context extends to the ‘historical antecedents’ by reference to what they may show.  Two, when an expression is transplanted from history, ‘it may have brought with it some of the soil in which it once grew, retaining a …

Purpose ‘at any price’

Laming v Electoral Commissioner [2025] HCA 31

Statutes rarely pursue one purpose 100%.  Did certain Facebook posts not giving sender particulars attract civil penalties at the maximum possible level?12 

Although an object was to deter non-compliance, it did not follow that penalties calculated on a multiple recipient basis were intended.  Section 15AA was of little assistance.  The deterrence …

Examples in legislation

Queensland v Johnston [2025] QCA 142

J was suspended from teaching pending unrelated criminal charges.  On acquittal, he sought lost pay on the basis he was ‘available to work’ at all times consistent with a statutory directive13.  J argued that an example in the directive of detention in a correctional facility operated to confine the directive to physical …

Regulations as exmats

Alliance Australia v Abawi [2025] NSWCA 85

An issue in this case was whether regulations made under a statute were extrinsic materials for the purposes of assisting determination of what ‘soft tissue injury’ means in the statute.  The court said ‘no’. 

Regulations made after enactment cannot be taken into account.  But those made at the same time as the statute …

Development consents

Monaltrie Area CAI v Santin [2025] NSWLEC 38

Subject to minor nuances, development consents are to be read in the same way as statutes7.  In Monaltrie, Robson J (at [37-40]) makes 2 valuable points. 

First, a development consent is to be interpreted ‘having regard to its enduring nature which encourages a fair but liberal reading of the …