Principles

Legislative history

Australian Rail Track v ARTBIU [2024] FCAFC 170

Legislative history is often significant in working out the ‘purpose or object’ in order to apply s 15AA11. 

After approval of an enterprise agreement, unions sought determination of various matters still in dispute.  This depended on representatives having ‘not settled all of the matters that were in dispute during bargaining …

Is ‘or’ binary?

Ibrahim v Greater Bendigo CC [2025] VSC 6

E115 reported a case where ‘or’ took an ‘ambulatory and cumulative’ operation14.  This case involved an application to extend time for starting work under a planning permit.  The statute allowed review of (a) a decision to refuse an extension of time ‘or’ (b) a failure to extend time within a …

Mathematical logic

Martinus Rail v Qube (No 3) [2024] NSWSC 1483

An adjudicator awarded full costs where, on his reasoning, only 96.07% was allowable.  The question was whether this involved jurisdictional error due to ‘legal unreasonableness’.  This, noted Parker J (at [48]), was a question of statutory interpretation.

It was held the error was simply arithmetical, ‘not a contestable error of legal …

Power and duty

Gill v Liverpool City Council [2024] NSWLEC 133

Mortgagees of land compulsorily acquired objected to the compensation amount offered.  The issue was whether the mortgagees could force joinder of the owner, who had not objected to the offer.  The statute said that the court ‘may order that any other person [with an interest] be joined as a party’6.…

Contractual basics

Elisha v Vision Australia [2024] HCA 50

The High Court rarely says very much about the basic principles applied in working out what a contract means.  In this case (at [38]), the plurality stated –

Serious High Court dicta

Cipla Australia v Novo Nordisk [2024] FCA 1414

E86 reported on Hill v Zuda Pty Ltd, where the High Court said that it expects lower courts to follow ‘seriously considered dicta’ of a majority of that court13.  Much has been said about the outworking of this principle since it was reconfirmed in 202214.

Perram J …

Awareness of cases

Vicinity Funds v Commissioner [2024] VSC 658

This case is about duties payable on transfer of Myer sites in Melbourne.  Each site was subject to a 299 year lease, with rent of $1pa.  Duty was payable on the greater of consideration and unencumbered value7.  Were the leases an ‘encumbrance’?  Answer ‘no’. 

Parliament is generally presumed to be aware …

Meaning of ‘or’

Williams v Toyota Motor Corp [2024] HCA 38

The little word ‘or’ often causes problems.  Here, it was used between paragraphs in the definition of ‘affected person’ in manufacturer damage clauses. 

Usually ‘or’ is read disjunctively to produce discrete options to be met.  Jagot J (at [155]) confirmed that this is not always the case, and that ‘or’ may have …

Headings

FCT v Patrix Prestige [2024] FCAFC 148

Headings are taken into account in interpretation11, but their practical impact varies.  One issue in this case was the effect of the phrase ‘Changes of use’ in headings to luxury car tax adjustment provisions12. 

The key point made by the court (at [19]) was that headings are ‘often …

Meaning of ‘in relation to’

FCT v Esso Australia [2024] FCAFC 151

The meaning of phrases like ‘in relation to’ depends on context.  The issue in this case was whether fees paid to Esso under contract were ‘assessable tolling receipts’ for being ‘consideration receivable … in relation to the processing of … internal petroleum’14.

Context is determined by the text, purpose and history, …