Episode 31

iNOW! is a modest initiative from the ATO built on a simple idea – ‘anyone who reads legislation and writes down what it means needs to know this stuff’.  Over 140 cases and 31 episodes later, iNOW! is an accessible toolkit of principle and practice.  This year alone, AustLII will record over 2500 cases dealing with the subject in one …

Judicial wrongness

Kemp v Medical Board of Australia [2017] VSC 691

When may a court overturn a longstanding decision on interpretation?  There is a reluctance to do so unless the earlier decision is clearly wrong2.  But, it is no part of the judicial role to perpetuate error, even where provisions have been re-enacted3.  Decided cases also should not …

Meaning of ‘lodged’

Kaczmarski v Legal Services Board [2017] VSC 690

The statute allowed Kaczmarski 7 days to appeal a notice posted on 1 May.  He emailed his appeal at 7.43pm on 10 May.  Did he lodge in time?  A thing is ‘lodged’ if it is deposited in person (or electronically) and accepted, said the judge (at [32-36]).  An email is ‘lodged’ when …

Appeal rights

Lewis v Sergeant Riley [2017] NSWCA 272

What if 2 Acts provide separate rights of appeal from the same proceedings?  In this case: one to the District Court, one to the Supreme Court.  The answer, said Basten JA (at [5, 21]), is not to assume inconsistency, but instead to try and give each provision an operation consistent with its terms.  …

Composite provisions

FCT v Hacon Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 181

This case confirms that the ATO can decline to make a private ruling where it ‘would depend on which assumptions were made about a future event’11.  One argument rejected (at [21-27]), however, was that provisions about making private rulings and applying for them should ‘be read as a composite’12…

Episode 30

Many tax provisions confer power on the Commissioner to make decisions on being personally ‘satisfied’ that some factual precondition or other has been met1.  In the same-sex marriage case, the High Court re-stated some basic principles regarding ‘official satisfaction’2.  They said (at [109]) that the ‘satisfaction must be formed reasonably and on a correct understanding of …

Extrinsic materials

Dinov v Allianz Australia [2017] NSWCA 270

This case (at [65-67]) tells us to construe the text of the law, not language ‘used in the second reading speech or in some explanatory memorandum.’  Statements in explanatory materials about intention ‘cannot overcome the need to carefully consider the words of the statute to ascertain its meaning.7’

In this case, …

Alpha and omega

NW Melbourne Recycling v CSR [2017] VSC 647

In this land tax refund case, it was said (at 41]) that the provisions in question were the ‘alpha and omega of the judicial task of statutory construction’8.  The phrase ‘alpha and omega’ has biblical overtones9, but in this context means no more than ‘the beginning and the …

Legislative examples

Keris Pty Ltd v DFCT [2017] FCAFC 164

This security deposit case illustrates how examples in legislation can impact on interpretation.  An example said the Commissioner could require additional security in certain cases.  The court observed (at [28]) that the example was consistent with the forward-looking aspect of the power.

Section 15AD12 says that an example is not exhaustive …

Industrial awards

Tomvald v Toll Transport [2017] FCA 1208

Although industrial agreements are generally to be construed with a degree of latitude or generosity, a court is not free to read into them preconceived notions of fairness.  Nor, said Flick J (at [37-38]), are awards to be read ‘in a vacuum divorced from industrial realities’15.  Context is important.

The issue …