Episode 29

When does failure to comply with statutory conditions invalidate some formal act?  In Forrest & Forrest1, a mineralisation report had not been provided with the application for a mining lease2.  It was provided later, however, and it was before the minister3.  Whether lateness was fatal depended on purpose, language and consequences.  No decisive rule …

Extrinsic material

Koundouris v Owners Unit Plan [2017] ACTCA 36

Planning laws commonly impose warranties for work quality on builders.  It was argued that  explanatory statements with the Act meant a builder had to be party to the sale contract for warranties to apply6.  Here there was an interposed entity. 

The appeal court said (at [41]) the explanatory statements…

Legislative intent

Joseph v Worthington [2017] VSC 501

A cardinal rule of interpretation has always been to give effect to legislative intent7.  This case (at [31]) reminds us that discovering intention is ‘an objective process ascertained by interpreting the statute’. 

It is not any subjective intention of the legislature which is relevant, but rather the ‘objective meaning’ of the provisions…

Legislative intervention

Ghamrawi v R [2017] NSWCCA 195

Constructional choice is one thing, but statutory words, even when read in their widest context, only stretch so far.  Ghamrawi was convicted of ‘break and enter’ to commit assault12.  He had permission to enter, however, and used no trick or threat. 

Law reform elsewhere had extended the meaning of ‘break’, but the …

Telephone books

Oreb v ASIC (No 2) [2017] FCAFC 49

The court (at [54]) referred to the ‘massive and over complex verbiage’ of the 2500 page Corporations Act, where professionals and judges ‘must navigate tortuous, mind-numbingly detailed, cascading provisions’.  These ‘telephone books’ enacted ‘at huge cost to the community’14 raise the need for more principles-based drafting, the court said. 

This …

Episode 28

If you read only one case on interpretation in 2017, make it this one – SZTAL v Minister1.  The majority (at [14]) state the basics, but it is Gageler J (at [34-43]) who digs deeper into the problem-solving2.  The issue was the meaning of ‘intention’ in a protection visa context3.  Gageler J stressed the …

Mere inconvenience

Oreb v ASIC (No 2) [2017] FCAFC 49

Mere inconvenience of result is not enough to force interpretation6 – this is basic.  ASIC can disqualify officers within 12 months of ceasing their duties, if the company ‘was wound up’7.  Does winding up need to be complete?  If ‘yes’, it would prejudice ASIC powers and go beyond mere …

Delegated legislation

4nature v Centennial Springvale [2017] NSWCA 191

Episode 13 mentioned court comments that delegated legislation, being ‘less carefully drafted’, is to be ‘less keenly scrutinised’.  Not everyone agrees8.  In 4nature (at [45]), an appeal judge has now denied that ‘there is some general principle requiring laxity or flexibility in construing delegated legislation, or statutory instruments generally’. 

The correct …

Backdated agreements

CCSR v Smeaton Grange [2017] NSWCA 184

In 1952, it was said it was ‘beyond the power of the gods … to alter the past’9.  This case (at [5-15]) applies that sentiment in the context of disclaimer by the object of a discretionary trust.  Private parties may agree that legal relations between them began from some date in …

Dictionaries (again)

Hunter’s Hill Council v Minister [2017] NSWCA 188

Basten JA in this council amalgamation case (at [76-83]) recalls the limits of using dictionaries.  Resort to them is ‘rarely favoured’11, he said, though not for ‘some dismissive or precious attitude’.  It is more because they concern common usage, which may not be reflected in the statutory context.  They may …