Episode 21

Uber BV v Commissioner [2017] FCA 110

Many cases touch on statutory interpretation in some way, but few are about almost nothing else.  Uber BV is one of them.  The GST law defines ‘taxi travel’ to mean ‘travel that involves transporting passengers, by taxi or limousine, for fares’.  Griffiths J said that ‘taxi’ takes its ordinary meaning and that …

Episode 20

Contractual interpretation

Resolution of tax disputes depends on applying the law as it is to the facts as found.  If the facts are wrong, so usually will be the tax.  Findings of fact often depend on contractual interpretation, so it’s important to know the basics here.  As the High Court restated recently1, it’s an objective approach according to …

Episode 19

Justice John Logan of the Federal Court makes two points in a recent paper about statutory interpretation1.  The first is that a ‘plethora of prescription’ in legislation ‘has, almost exponentially, increased the construction tasks a member of the [AAT] may be called upon to confront’2.  The second is that interpretational principles ‘do not differ as between …

Double Tax Agreements

Bywater Investments v FCT [2016] HCA 45

Episode 3 dealt with how to approach the interpretation of DTAs.  Gordon J in this case (at [145-150]) provides further guidance in the context of a dispute about residency for income tax purposes. 

Where a DTA is set out in an Act in the same words, the ‘transposed text should bear the same …

Meaning of ‘under’

Siddique v Martin [2016] VSCA 274 

The word ‘under’ is common in statutes.  In this case, the court had power to direct that items seized ‘under a search warrant’ be returned to their owner.  A magistrate had held he could not return things seized by police but not listed on the warrant6. 

The court (at [19]) quoted a …

Principle of legality

Jeremiah v Lawrie [2016] NTCA 6

Plaintiff S99 [2016] FCA 483

Episode 13 dealt with the ‘principle of legality’ that clear words are needed to interfere with important common law rights and doctrines.  These two cases show the flexibility with which it may apply in practice.  In Jeremiah (at [76-84]), validity of a search warrant was upheld despite interference with …

Connection phrases

R v Kay [2016] QCA 269

It is nothing new to observe, as this case does (at [26]), that common connection phrases like ‘in relation to’ and ‘in connection with’ often raise problems.  The precise degree of connection fluctuates depending on purpose and context11, including ‘the subject matter of the inquiry, the legislative history, and the facts of …

Episode 18

Have you ever known (or thought you’ve known) the purpose of a provision because you were involved, in one way or another, in its drafting?  You may have spoken to someone who claims to have written the law and is dead-set certain what they meant.  This may be interesting but, when it comes to interpretation, it is irrelevant.  As iNOW!…

Later amendments

AQO v Minister [2016] NSWCA 248 

Later amendments can inform the interpretation of an earlier version of the Act, but only where the earlier provision is ambiguous and the amendment wasn’t simply meant to clarify the law and remove doubt2.  Even then, you should only use later amendments in limited circumstances – for example, to reject an interpretation …

General & specific words

Van Heerden v Hawkins [2016] WASCA 42

If a provision mentions several specific things of the same type, and ‘other’ things generally, those ‘other’ things may also need to be of that type4.  However, the specific things must have something in common – you must be able to identify a ‘genus’5.  iTip – don’t apply this …