Express powers

FCT v Croft [2016] QSC 190

If an Act expressly confers a specific power constrained by certain conditions, it may implicitly exclude the use of more general powers that could otherwise have achieved the same result7.  However, like the ‘express references’ rule in Episode 16, this needs to be supported by context, and it shouldn’t be the only …

Similar Acts

Byrne v Owners [2016] WASC 153

It is presumed, subject to contrary intent, that similar expressions attract the same meaning in similar statutes11 – in pari materia.  Tax cases and a recent High Court decision illustrate the idea12.  Pritchard J in this case (at [131]) observed that the presumption only applies between statutes, not where a …

Episode 17

The Acts Interpretation Act – a statutory Cabinet of Curiosities

It is not uncommon for a statute to be silent on something that appears to leave a hole in its operation, such as undefined words that obviously should be, unaddressed mechanical matters, and other esoteric issues.  Before cursing the drafters and throwing the statute across the room in frustration, look …

Definitions

Many common words like ‘business day’, ‘document’, ‘individual’, ‘land’, ‘person’ or ‘writing’ are defined in AIA s 2B.  This dictionary should always be your starting point, though it is just a drafting convenience and, like the rest of the AIA, it is displaced by contrary intention in the Act it is applied to (s 2(2))1…

Approved forms

Prescribed forms of documents are common in tax laws.  Under AIA s 25C, strict compliance with these forms isn’t necessary and substantial compliance is sufficient.  This is determined by considering the purpose of the form and its contents as a whole, not by analysing its individual parts separately4.  Failure to use the correct form isn’t necessarily fatal…

Examples

Like notes, examples are part of the Act but their interpretive status is unclear9.  Under AIA s 15AD(a), they are ‘not exhaustive’ and can’t limit a provision’s scope.  AIA s 15AD(b) used to say that a provision overrides its example if the two are inconsistent.  It was rewritten in 2011 and now says ‘the example may extend …

Amendments & repeals

These are governed by rules in AIA ss 7-11B.  iNOW! has previously discussed the presumption against retrospectivity in s 7(2) and the cross-reference rules in s 1011.  Section 7(1) also says that if a repealing Act or an Act altering the common law is itself repealed, the original law isn’t automatically revived.

Section 11B says that …

Episode 16

Developments in statutory interpretation case law are often seen to be of greatest relevance to those whose job it is to advise on or argue about the operation of existing statutes.  In my opinion, they are just as relevant for those who design statutes, as they need to ensure that government policy can be achieved when the law is interpreted …

Ordinary & trade meaning

The Queen v A L [2016] VSCA 156

How do you interpret everyday words in a statute when they also have a specialised trade or technical meaning?  Normally words take their ordinary meaning – particularly since parliament can define a word if it is meant to have a special meaning1.  However, context, phrasing or subject matter may show …

Words of judgments

Military Rehabilitation v May [2016] HCA 19 

This case (at [52]) reminds us that when a judge explains what statutory words mean, their reformulation cannot be substituted for those words and construed as if it were the statutory text3.  Unlike statutes, the meaning of judgments isn’t found by analysing the specific words used by the judge.  Instead, read …